It all started innocently enough a month ago. Seeking some joy in having all my time to myself I logged onto my facebook account after jotting down the details of my temp assignment. Rarely checking the thing, I noticed that I had a friend request.
From my ex.
I’m never too sure what qualifies as an ex since I’ve never been in an official relationship, but it’s safe to say that connection with this person started as an epistolary flirtation about our love of food. I had hoped that our connection would be long lasting, but alas it was not. Last Christmas I had bought him a gift certificate for a maasage when he surprised me with even bigger news– he was breaking up with me. His email announcing his desire to not see me anymore was philosophical, poetic almost. He didn’t want to be in a relationship and he sensed that I wanted that.
So with all of our history online and offline, of course I couldn’t accept his friend request. It’s been almost a year since he obliterated all contact we had– and I didn’t want to see his icon on my page. So I asked him, why are you sending me this. And then he wrote back: I was wrong to push you out of my life, and I am sorry.
That apology felt really good. I felt vindicated, excited in a way. This was him telling me that what transpired between us wasn’t my fault, because, he’s finally said he was sorry. All that goodness stayed for about ten minutes, and then it just hurt like hell. Why was he contacting me? I had gone to great lengths to get over what happened, and then my experience with him washing over me. The evasiness, the unreturned phone calls, the fact that he was never available, or honest in regards to how he felt about me. But it’s been almost a year and I’m trying to move on emotionally from it and I’ve went through a lot since then and I was happy acting like he didn’t exist and staying out of his world and respecting his need for space but now all of sudden he’s sorry. It felt like that.
Apologies are difficult, impossible almost. Humans like hearing they’re right, which ultimately means no one likes being told they’re wrong. I know I don’t. And apologies have this heavy emotional level to them because it’s when people have to engage in being wrong, as opposed to when things are right and free and fun. I know I hate apologizing. Partially because I had to do it all the time with my mom. (“Sorry for waking you up.” “I’m sorry I embarrassed you in the video store.” “I’m sorry for jumping into your lap. I was just excited because I hadn’t seen you all” I had to say to her when I was seven). She’s never apologized for anything she’s done to me, because she sees herself as a human who makes mistakes, and if you love someone, you shouldn’t ask for that. You should just know that person has needs and you should let their transgression go.
That of course is the against the nature of apologizing. When it comes to saying you’re sorry, and you geniunely mean it, the hard work goes on the other person because they have to decide if they want to accept your apology. Apologizing can sometimes be a band-aid approach, but saying you were wrong cuts into a deep wound, and implies you may want to heal that wound. We continued to converse, and he confessed that he knew I loved him, but he just saw me as a friend all along, and when he saw how crazy I was about him he took advantage of that. His response hurt because it caused me to relive all of that which, I am going to assume was way worse for me than it was for him. I’m still assessing whether it would be worth it to have him back in my life.
This isn’t my first experience with exes who return. Three months after we agreed to stop speaking (or he hung up on me) my first love sent me an email saying he missed me. That sent me into an emotional tailspin and three hours, two bottles of wine, a Keisha Cole album and a box of Kleenex later, I had the strength to not respond. Even though he was saying what I wanted to hear, I knew deep down it was because he no longer had me as an emotional anchor.
The other tricky part is that he’s not only asking me to forgive him (which I do) he’s asking to be friends. He thinks that we could get together and make dinner or split a bottle of wine! This is also hard because I’ve worked a lot to no longer care about him, but he’s asking me to care. I’ve also had friends who were exes, or exes who were friends. I’m not sure which came first. She was girl a hooked up with several times only for her to say she couldn’t fall in love with me, because I seemed too much like a goody two shoes, but she wanted to be my friend. The problem is that all of issues we had when we were hooking up resurfaced in the friendship with a vengance. She wouldn’t return my phone calls for weeks but show up at my door in the middle of the night. She’d complain about the people she was sleeping with and of course this info is a little unwanted because we used to sleep together, and she’d say that if she could get her senses straight she could fall for someone like me because I was loyal, loving, caring, honest (but kinda boring). Whenever I’d call her out about not being a good friend to me with her evasiness and selfish behavior she’d just throw it in my face that I knew she was like that all along, why was I was tripping? It took me too long to figure out that being her friend was emotionally preventing me from moving on to a better suited romantic relationship, and when I finally got the courage to cut it off, I felt terrible. She did email me once after that, but I haven’t heard from her again. I’m better able to put that experience behind me since we’re no longer in contact and I can move on with my life. When we were trying to be friends I felt profoundly disempowered by her behavior, and this nagging suspicion started to take over me (because she said I’m settled and women like more excitement, I may never find anyone who likes me) which may have sabatoged my emotional progress.
All these fears I bring to the table when my second love contacted me. Would we really be able to be friends? Better yet, would I want to cook for him again? I mean, I do have a wonderful butternut squash soup he’d greatly appreciate, but I don’t want to make anything for him. I’m not even sure if I want him to touch me again. It’s nauseating knowing that someone you loved so much didn’t care about you. I’ve relayed this situation to my friends, one of his casual friends, my therapist, even my mom, and there’s been a concencus. I really don’t have to be his friend if I don’t want to after what happened between us, but I need to get used to fact that he exists, because we live in the same city, occupy the same spaces and even share mutual friends. If I were to re-enter his life it would have to gradual, and he’d need to seriously work on building trust.
But do I really want to see him with his new girlfriend? No, no I do not. I don’t think I’m emotionally prepared for that. And no matter how rational I can get (I should be over it, there are other fish in the sea etc.) my mind is saying I should spend that energy finding someone real to love, and my heart is just saying although I appreciate his apology because it’s helped me work through some trust issues, I am not ready to let him back into my life yet. He’s asking for forgiveness; in turn I’m asking for his patience. If he wants to be my friend as much as he says he does, he’ll grant me that. More importantly, he’ll understand.